Comparison of two Anti Snake Venom protocols in hemotoxic snake bite: A randomized trial

Abstract

The dose of Anti Snake Venom (ASV) in hemotoxic snake bite depends on the amount of venom injected and species of snake. All trials in South East Asia have studied different doses of ASV, wherein the ASV in high dose group itself was lower than the dose that is recommended in National protocol. These studies favored low dose protocol, as there was no difference in mortality and morbidity between the groups. So, this study intended to assess the efficacy of National protocol in reducing morbidity and mortality in hemotoxic snake bite in comparison to current protocol followed in institution. This was an open label randomized trial of 140 hemotoxic snakebite patients. Group A received national protocol: initial dose of 100 ml followed by 100 ml 6th hourly till 20-minute Whole Blood Clotting Time (20WBCT) was less than 20 minutes or 300 ml of ASV was given, whichever was earlier. Group B received 70 ml followed by 30 ml every 6th hourly until two consecutive 20WBCT were less than 20 minutes. There was no statistical difference in the amount of ASV required in both the groups. Mortality and acute kidney injury were higher in group A (statistically not significant), probably due to sicker patients in that group. There was no relapse of clotting time abnormality in both the groups. In a significant number of patients (12%), clotting time was persistently prolonged till death. We found that the use of National ASV dosing protocol did not decrease the mortality and morbidity.